You putting Mickey's deaths in Mrs. Loomis' session was KILLING me

I love how when he said mickey killed he put the victims in the nancy section

The "knowing glance" that Billy gives Stu when he whips around the house to catch Sid while everyone else is filing out feels like such confirmation that he killed Tatum. It's like he's non-verbally communicating "everything went to plan, I took care of her" to Stu.

Crazy how Roman basically has the most kills since he soloing all by himself

Roman definitely has the most since he worked alone. It also kind of makes sense since he was the original "final boss" of the series. I'm not a fan of Charlie but the man knew how to take people out. The Kirche's seem to end up having a lot of survivors. Mickey was supposedly active before the film, so he arguably has a higher body count, but in terms of ghostface murders then Roman takes it.

I think Tatum was killed by Billy, but I would actually love it if Stu was behind it just from the emotional standpoint. It was betrayal either way from her boyfriend's side obviously, but still, if he executed the kill it would hit even harder.

I still say Mickey was the best ghost face. The most psycho, sadistic, and believable

Roman Bridger director AND BROTHER 😎

I’m glad you brought up the Charlie Renaissance because if they do go for a more true crime era in the franchise, I think it would be dope if we got a future installment where a we’ve moved past the obsession with Stab and our new Ghostface has stumbled across the actual footage of the 2011 killings.

My first instinct without putting thought into it is to say Roman because he's the only solo boy but I'm excited to watch this breakdown and see a more accurate analysis.

It’s kind of funny how Billy only killed women, while Stu only killed men.

Tara has the best self defense kill just by her hobbling around and giving a good one liner afterwards. I literally laughed when that happened.

Mickey has the highest kill count because he already was a serial killer before Scream 2. So he must have at least 3 kills before he became Ghostface. As Ghostface he has 7 kills. Then Roman with 9 kills and Charlie with 7-8 kills. Billy 4 kills, Stu 3 kills, Jill 3 kills (Jenny, Trevor and Charlie), Amber 3 kills and Richie 3 kills. Wayne has 7 kills, Ethan 3 kills. Nancy and Quinn both have 1 kill.

I love your breakdowns and am excited for your remakes of 1-4. Make them as long as you want! 😂

I always figured Roman had the most kills in the franchise. Great video analysis 😁!

I still think it makes more sense for Jill to have killed the cops and her mother. Still, good for both Mickey and Roman for being two of the most proficient Ghostfaces

We need a scream prequel but it doesn’t necessarily have to be a horror. We need to see Roman being upset that Maureen Prescott rejected him and interacting with Billy after Mrs. Loomis leaves him. When need to get in the psyche of Billy and how he used Sidney to get to her mother AND how he was secretly dating Samantha’s mom. Did Samantha’s mom know what was going on? We also need to see how Billy persuaded Stu into getting involved and how they felt killing Casey Becker.

🎵 Billy, Stu, Mickey🎵 Nancy, Roman, Charlie 🎵 Jill, Amber, Richie 🎵 has a good ring to it.😂 The way I read your column section.

I feel Billy did kill himbry, the gutting fact could be setting up the fact he was gonna frame stu if things went wrong, and I feel it goes to show how Billy was prepared for anything. I mean if the police analyzed the bodies they would find 2 distince patterns.

As always, maintaining Tatum for Stu. Based on the progression of Halloween, Billy shows up an hour after Tatum dies, and someone had to hang Himbry. There’s no way they do that in the day, and they’d do it as close as possible to their finale to ensure cops were distracted/no one found him too soon. Stu simply could not have hung Himbry, he was at the party. When Tatum died, Billy was hanging Himbry. Just the most logical to me by far.

Those who killed whos are classic!! Would love to see more in depth ones

Great video Zack. Was here when you uploaded your original who killed whos.. be great to see you update them, cant wait 🙏

You always make the best videos man....love them...love them 😊💙

ilysm you NEVER disappoint me! thank you for another banger bby💕

Amazing video Zack! You never disappoint. It’s always a good day when you post ❤🙌🐐

I love how often Zack says Bodega!

I had a few different opinions on some of the killings but i love the fact that this lists also includes everything you spoke with Eddy about on cherry picker which means he also convinced you in some ppints. Now this list matches 100% my theory so its ni e to have this as an overview to come back to ❤

Stu running off was to tell Billy that everything was good to go (made clear as much during the deleted scene script). It was still Billy that killed Himbry IMO.

Wayne left his mask on the floor in bodega. But I bet they have cameras there. That's curious, he should've cover the face with something else. This thing with cameras in scream movies always disturbed me. It never interrupted killers or helped to reveal them.

Nice! Next one please: Which Ghostface had the most unsuccesful attacks?

always love the scream vids, scream 4 is slept on

Roman and Charlie would have tied if Kirby hadn’t survived. Wow.

Very good video, Zack. I'm very pleased! 😊👍

I find this very fascinating videos you work really hard on this

Love the horror content keep it up

ive never been this early before! love your videos

This guy is awesome!!!

So Quinn only killed 1 person, but she tried to kill 5, Gale, Mindy, Chad, & Sam being the failures. Does that make her the worst Ghostface statistically?

Thank you Zack!

yhur uploads never disappoint me 😌 also i agree wit EVERYTHING yhu said , like i thought it was jus me - i never have n never will believe angelina was roman’s partner or else those conspiracists might as well add dat derek , hallie , nancy + cotton were S2’s killers , not mickey (tho they never do n shouldn’t cause it doesn’t count , jus like angelina) - also same , while im not charlie’s biggest fan (but he’s a lil higher on my ranking) ppl rlly give jill most credit as if they haven’t actually watched S4 n are jus so ignorantly biased cause like yhu said , i too have always believed deleted scenes are canon cause they’re still innuh movie (of which yhu can watch onnuh guide/main menu if yhu physically own it) but got cut out which i wish dint happen but wut can ya do , vs alternative scenes of which are basically fa different n unused scripts such as S2 + S3’s hectic bts shooting schedule .. i was srsly losing my shit til yhu literally said everything i’ve always thought/believed n i kid yhu not , i ended up screaming while clapping wit fricking joy cause jus like me , yhu’re actually using context clues n not like sum of these “fans” who’re jus all “well i guess it’d make more sense if …” ANYWAY yhu’re doin awesome as always my dude , keep it up 🖤

Zack will you be uploading your thoughts on the Scream 3 assembly footage at some point in the future? Some of the cut scenes really connect the film together more its crazy to see

Well done video overall!

GREAT VIDEO 😃👍 Enjoy your page btw! Could you do a motive pov video of every GF?

11:30 That always reminds me of in the original Scream, Sidney runs to the school bathroom after running into Billy, and listens to the cheerleader and her friend accuse Sidney of being the murderer, and a ghostface pops out of a toilet stall. Hes unarmed, and THAT SAME DAY earlier in the scene, we see a student running down the hall screaming in a Ghostface mask, they get pulled into Principal Himbrys office later. I agree, I think the Ghostface outside Olivia's house in 4 was just a prankster. Maybe he was out to recreate the clotheslines scene from Halloween 1978 outside Jill or Olivia's windows...

Jason and the other guy kinda feel more like a Quinn or Ethan thing, since they would have been the most feasible to be in their class with Tara and Mindy. I can’t personally imagine Wayne finding it very important to get some random unrelated college kids, and I think Quinn showed a little more bloodlust than to only have one killer. Also I think Paul was probably Quinn’s.

When I watched Scream, I wasn't sure, but whenever Ghostface was thrown around, it sounded awfully like Skeet Ulrich, so either the stunt actor sounded remarkabley like Skeet, or they recorded Skeet grunting like he was getting thrown around.

Nice video

Very nice list. These are my thoughts Billy: 4 Kills Stu: 2 Kills Mickey : 7 Kills Nancy: 1 Kill Roman: 9 Kills Charlie: 7 Kills Jill: 2 Kills Richie: 2 Kills Amber: 4 Kills Jason: 1 Kill Wayne: 6 Kills Ethan: 2 Kills Quinn: 1 Kill Sam: 3 Kills Tara: 1 Kill Cotton: 1 Kill Dewey: 1 Kill Sydney: 4 Kills(3 if Stu Macher still alive).

I think for Greg and Jason's kills in the apartment this would have been Wayne because of how he 'finds' Sam's drivers license which i think was taken prior to the movie's beginning by Quinn and given to Wayne to plant at the scene as he would have been first on scene given he killed them and would be able to leave the drivers license at the scene just like when he was first at the scene to swap out Quinn's body for a fake one at Sam's apartment.

Roman takes the crown as he a should...

I kept thinking Ethan killed Jason and not Wayne because of the comment the killer makes about not giving a fuck about movies. I felt like it was implied that Wayne was invested in his "favorite" sons hobbies despite them being unconventional. Ethan seemed hurt/jealous by Wayne's love for Richie.

Hey Zack speaking of scream 3 i always remember of an alternate opening scene where cotton tries to escape through the roof and then gets caught but i cant seem to find it anywhere.

I am going to guess Roman because he was the only killer thus didn't have to share kills with a partner.

Here This What I Mostly Know... Billy Loomis: 3 Kills. Stu Macher: 2 Kills. Mickey Altieri: 7 Kills. Nancy Loomis: 1 Kill. Roman Bridger: 9 Kills. Jill Roberts: 5 Kills. Charlie Walker: 5 Kills. Amber Freeman: 4 Kills. Richie Kirsch: 2 Kills. Jason Carvey: 1 Kill. Ethan Landry: 2 Kills. Quinn Bailey: 1 Kill. Wayne Bailey: 6 Kills.

Could you do your top 10/20 favourite characters in Scream franchise?

Another thing for the Wes kill having to be Richie is there is no way Amber could have overpowered Wes like that just mass wise but Richie putting his body weight behind it definitely could.

Hey zack. I noticed that in this video you seem to be a lot less enthusiastic or excited about making this video. If your lack of energy happens to be anything with mental health or something, know that Scream Team is here for you and feel free to reach out to me or someone else if you happen to need someone to talk to ❤

I think you also have to look at the dialog, the things ghost face was saying on the phone is what gave scream 5 away for me

charlie was on fire (even tough eh got badly betrayed) my second favorite ghostface by far

Theory for Scream 7 incoming: alright, here me out. I was reading through the comments and saw someone talking about a ghostface cult involving stu's return. maybe its just me but I LOVE this idea. I think it can drive the story away from 'the core four' as if Stu is the leader of this 'cult' he has no real need to kill them. (However if they rehire them it could be because Sam is Billy's daughter) Making Stu return as this cult leader I think would have to be revealed around the middle of the movie however, since if you had hundreds of ghostfaces running around without a cast of potential killers it would just be very confusing and possibly boring. I think they should make Mark (Sidney's husband) get kidnapped to bring Sidney back to Woodsboro. After she gets there it could be revealed that Gales healed in the hospital from her attack in scream 6, bringing back 2 of the franchises main characters for this movie. Since Sidney doesn't actually live in Woodsboro, she could stay with Dewey and Tatum's family, adding the 'suspects' aspect of a regular scream movie. Adding to this, you could have new police officers, since the deaths of Judy and Dewey the franchise is lacking in its police officer character 😭 If they don't do this, they could even add something as simple as 'its a high school reunion' or something like that and its classic 'teenage cast' turns into an adult cast with past teenagers from the same school of the first movie. Sounds weird - I know, but I don't really see how they'll incorporate teenagers into a new reboot story with Sidney Prescott. Anyway, back on track - After people around them start dying, Sidney could find Mark while the movie focuses on her, gale and mark trying to leave town from Ghostface, who seems to appear everywhere they run. It would be revealed that Stu is alive by him stabbing Mark, saying some silly line like 'The original cast is always better' or something goofy like that. - I realise this is so long that no one is probably going to read it but oh well - By the end of the movie I think Gale should've died, or been brutally attacked - on the verge of death - leaving Sidney alone. I think eventually nearing the end of the movie Sidney should somehow end up in this cults meetup spot. As she starts to look around Stu wanders in, but as Sidney is about to come out of hiding to kill him, a large amount of people wearing ghostface costumes would enter, with Stu giving this crazy speech. Then, I think the second killer should be revealed.. - Mark Kincaid. Sounds weird right? But i think its more possible then people realise. I'm gonna go over the story 1 more time fully. After the ending of the first movie, (correct me if I'm wrong cause its been a while) but I believe its never shown the police actually seeing Stu's body - again, maybe wrong I'm not sure - But maybe Stu survived and ran out the backdoor, the police are embarrassed about the fact he was able to get away so they tell everyone he's dead. And as I'm writing this I'm realising, in the easter egg of the 'is stu alive' video - there must have been some sort of reason for people to believe hes alive right? Like maybe Stu's family were angry that they never got to see their sons dead body.. So i think - Stu managed to escape out the back - the police check the woods behind his house, including the entire area, and find nothing. Confused about this - The police assume stu is dead from his wounds that Sidney tells them about, and that's that. Now here's where Mark comes in.. I've always found it weird how Roman managed to kill all those people by himself, let alone fake his own death halfway through. In the early draft of that script, there was supposed to be 2 killers, Angelina and Roman. By the end of the movie however, Angelina is dead. Meaning that there's no way she could come back. However, Mark is a red herring character, someone who was painted out to be the killer in the movie, but turns out he's innocent...Or is he? I believe that Mark and Roman had a deeper plan, however it backfired when Roman was killed. Luckily for Mark, Roman doesn't reveal their plan fully and Mark is able to run away freely. Mark, as a homicide detective, is hired by Stu's family to look into his death. Mark finds Stu, but instead of ratting him out to the police or his family, he continues his plan with Stu instead of Roman. Mark poses as her husband for YEARS, and even starts a family with her, Mark of course is crazy and doesn't care about any of it. Mark is the real mastermind here however, he makes Stu pose as the groups leader as even if Stu is caught out and killed - he can just run away free again! The motive? - there isnt one! Just 2 bloodthirsty maniacs with a whole group of people willing to kill for them. Anyway, back to the ending. After Stu's speech to the ghostface cult, after all the ghostfaces leave, Mark walks in, and goes over his plan with Stu one more time. However, Stu is hesitant about this, and there may even be some flashbacks to how Billy was controlling to him in ways. - We'll call it PTSD (ironic i know) But Stu gets in his own head and starts questioning Mark, leading to an argument where the 2 ghostface killers fight - to the death. Sidney witnesses her husband murder Stu. Sidney, shocked, starts crying uncontrollably, leading to one of the members of the ghostface cult finding her, however there's no chase, not yet. Mark makes Sidney come to him and goes off on his crazy killer reveal monologue - revealing he has no motive and simply just wants to see Sidney suffer. However - Stu isnt dead, Not yet, here comes Stu once again with his second back-from-the-dead scare, before Mark quickly kills him again. This however gives Sidney the big enough distraction she needs to run away while Mark is distracted by Stu. Throughout this chase Sidney sees the ghostfaces in a room all gathered together, and starts a fire. This is how she kills the ghostface cult. But Mark is still alive. The movie ends with Mark stabbing Sidney, but just before he pulls the knife out, he gets stabbed in the neck by Sidney Prescott. Sidney, after killing mark in a flaming building, begins to escape. The Police bust open the door with Kirby present, telling Sidney how sorry she is , only for Mark to also come back to life for one last scare to stab sidney multiple times. Sidney dies and the Scream movies are done. The next scene shows Sidneys funeral, with her kids, surviving cast members, and maybe even 'the core four' if rehired. Then someone, most likely Gale, is shown inside of where Sidney was staying, discovering and reading a written letter, the movie ends with Sidney reading out a note saying something about her final wishes and how shes not sure whether shell survive her trip to woodsboro. (Jesus this was long but i really enjoyed writing it) lemme know what you think😅 EDIT: Hate to make this longer but i thought id add, if the 'core four' do end up returning, i would like to see at least 1 if not 2 of them dead. One of them would need to be a twin, maybe Chad, and a carpenter sister, maybe Tara.

mickey and roman are the best ghostface in my opinion

I’m really curious to hear Zach’s opinions on Scream 7 after the changes, I bet he has some interesting theories on what will happen

If you do a redo who killed who of Scream 3, Angelina might have called the characters using Roman's voice because in a newly released scene of the assembly cut, we see Ghostface has Roman's voice downloaded alongside the other characters to use in the voice changer.

regarding Principal Himbry, if you wanted more logical evidence. you did say you believe stu performed the evisceration on casey, & later on its mention Himbry was found hung & gutted on the football post

I was always under the impression that Dewey killed Jennifer in Scream 3. Like for sure she would have died from Roman's stabs regardless, but Dewey shot her through the two-way mirror and that's when she went bloody ragdoll.

I like to think Angelina was involved with helping Roman do the killings, because otherwise there a a few inconsistencies that are hard to explain, but Roman most likely did do all the killing (except Tom Prinze technically killing himslef, due too Angelina probably setting off the gas) while Angelina was unaware Roman intended on killing her all along

You should do a who killed who of the series like you did for 5 And 6

Nancy almost got the high score 😂

3:40 I still think its 50/50on who killed tatum myself. Earlier on Randy suggests theres always some bull reason to kill your girlfriend to Stu and he seems to give a reaction like its a fair idea. Especially since he knows billy wants to kill his girlfriend Sid so maybe he wanted to get in on the idea. Plus ghostface slowly Slicing Tatums arms instead of just killing her quick always seemed more Stu style to me. I mean he he is also the one who sends her to the garage and who knows more abojt where the party guests are and the layout than him? Ah then again Billy would also have enough logic behind him to pull off the kill too.

Zack, do you think the ghostface actor/stuntman is super aware plays each kill like he's playing each different character?

I'm surprised that Charlie got 80% of the victims.

I have always thought that Phil's kill was a Nancy kill because it always seemed like the odd talking sounding like it was coming from an adult pretending to be a child, was a nod to Friday the 13th when Mrs. Vorhees was talking for jason whilst taking revenge, kind of like how Nancy was taking revenge for Billy.

Ethan was Bodega's Ghostface because it would be impossible for Wayne to leave a crime scene so quickly, a detective takes hours to analyze bodies and it would take around 9 hours to analyze everything and If you locate the location of Sam and Tara and Jason and Greg's apartment, it is around a 30-40 minute walk and 10-15 minutes by car. the location of Jason and Greg's apartment is close to AKB approximately 2 minutes walk Jason took 30-40 minutes to get to his apartment i.e. Wayne would take more than 15 minutes by car as the street was closed and Ghostface attacked 6 minutes After Wayne called Sam and it's impossible to be Wayne, the timing of the movie doesn't match up with Wayne being the Bodega's Ghostface. and when Tara pushes Ghostface you can hear Ethan's voice.

Charlie one of the best ghostface in costume period.

I may be making this up in my head but when Sid shoots Nancy, isn’t nancy’s pulse visible in the blood?

I could go either way on whether or not Billy or Stu was wearing Cotton's coat the night they killed Maureen. Billy has a similar hairstyle, but Stu is a more similar height.

Nancy killed Cici imo. It even looks like Lauri Metcalfe in the costume when she's chasing her up the stairs, she even looks shorter than Cici.

Roman is the goat. Debate me, I dare anyone. Bring forward your fave killers resume, ill show romans.

Richie definitely killed Vincent since he's the only one in that movie to do a knife wipe. Going on into 6, we see 2 of his family members do a knife wipe as well.

So mickey got 7, charlie got 8, and canonically at least, roman got 9. Goats in their own rights.

So excited for this lol

Disagree with you on Scream 1. Tatum vouched for Stu the night of Casey's killing so logically it would mean Billy killed both Casey and the boyfriend. Also Tatum's kill had to be Stu just based on the ghost face's movements.

18:59 I was told Ethan was the one in the Bottega store and billy killed the principal

How do you see the assembly cut for Scream 3 @ Zack Cherry?

I agree charlie is an underrated ghostface

Honestly, I think, Tatum was Stu's. I don't know, I was always pretty sure on that. Like just from a character motivation status, he was simping for Casey and probably just wanted to show dominance as a man by killing his gf. Of COURSE he could have snuck out for a few minutes there, he already did that with his "I'll be right back" moment. And mostly, I think the whole clumsyness of the ghostface in that scene (when she throws the beer bottles at him for example?) always screamed "Stu" to me. I could be wrong of course. You're the expert with a massive following.... Why am I even arguing this here? I must be an idiot......

“Angelina truthers” yes that is me

i think Billy was still the one who killed Steve because Tatum said that Stu was with her that night of murder

Id like to say in the alternate version, angelina killed sarah, christine and Tom. I think she was the one who turned the stove on, she was already in the house

3:30 if you look closely, stu is doing a gesture of air stabbing like he’s excited thinking about going to stab the principle. I think the Principle is Stu’s kill 100%

A couple things I see differently but outcome remains the same. Yeah, Roman has the most Ghostface kills.

jill and charlie are lowkey my favorites

Mais Himbry c'est Billy Le tueur a le masque de Billy, l'attaque est brutale, le proviseur ne se fait pas non plus ouvrir le ventre et tu as dit toi même dans ton analyse que c'était Billy 💀

My think: Billy: Maureen, Steve, Himbry, Kenny Stu: Casey, Tatum Nancy: Cici, Randy Mickey: Phill, Maureen, 2 bodyguards, Halie, Derek Roman: Christine, Cotton, Sarah, Stone, Tom, Angelina, Tyson, Jennifer, John Jill: Marnie, Jenny, Rebeca, 2 cops, Kate, Trevor Charlie: Olivia, Robbie Richie: Judy, Wes, Cop Amber: Vince, Dewey, Liv Wayne: Greg, Jason, Paul, Anika Ethan: 3 bodega guys Quinn: Dr. Stone, Brooks

Can i ask what platform ur using for chart

My personal who killed who Opinions Billy- Maureen (with the help of Stu), Casey (with Stu’s help hanging her), principal Himbrey, Tatum. Stu- Maureen (with Billy’s help), Steve, helped Billy hang Casey, & Kenny. Mickey- Everyone except for Randy, however Sidney’s house attack & who sliced Dereks arm could honestly of been either of them Nancy Loomis- Randy Charlie- Everyone except for Trevor & himself Jill- Trevor & Charlie Amber- Judy, Officer Clay, Dewey, Liv Richie- Vince & Wes Jason- Laura Wayne- Gregg, Jason, Bodega Guy one two & three, & likely doctor stone Ethan- Paul 2.0 & Anika Quinn- Brooks So overall, Billy- 4 Kills Stu- 2-4 Kills Mickey- 7 Kills Nancy- 1 Kill Charlie- 8 Kills Jill- 2 Kills Amber- 4 Kills Richie- 2 Kills Wayne- 6 Kills Ethan- 2 Kills Quinn- 1 Kill

Hey, can you do a "who killed who" in scary movie? 😁

I'm still always confused on who made the phone call to Sid in Scream 4 after Olivia's death. Because with a line like "I'm gonna slit your eyelids in half so you don't blink when I stab you in the face!" feels VERY Jill. She HATED Sidney. But this was very clearly a Charlie kill. And I'm not sure if Jill would risk making the call while IN Olivia's house cause she came rushing up the stairs right after Sid threw the phone. But then again Ghostface DID have one of the most maniacal laughs in the entire franchise during that call too at the end...it's a toss up.

I think if we put these Ghostfaces against each other, Mickey would definitely take the Win. Being the only Ghostface who was already an active serial killer probably even a hitman no pun intended before scream, meanwhile the rest are mostly students except for Roman, Nancy, Wayne, and Richie

Yo zack talk about the new drama with scream 7. Thats some good content for you